42nd Street at Kilworth House Theatre Review
Written by Emmie for Theatre & Tonic
Disclaimer: Gifted tickets in exchange for an honest review
For nearly two decades, Kilworth House has captivated audiences with top-tier musical productions in its stunning open-air theatre in South Leicestershire. With past hits on their stage like Singin’ in the Rain and Half A Sixpence earning our seal of approval, this year’s dazzling production of 42nd Street might just steal the show.
42nd Street is a staple in musical theatre history. First premiering on Broadway back in 1980, the story is a glittering homage to the golden age of musicals and showbiz dreams. Based on the 1933 of the same name (and which starred Ruby Keeler and Dick Powell in it), the musical features some of the most iconic songs of all time, including “We’re in the Money” and “Lullaby of Broadway”. 42nd Street made a recent revival at Theatre Royal Drury Lane in 2017, as well as a Made at Curve production in 2023.
The story follows the thriving theatre producer Julian Marsh, played by Lewis Griffiths, as he produces the next big hit musical, Pretty Lady, during the Great Depression. To secure his financial success, he casts Broadway star Dorothy Brock (Michelle Bishop) as the leading lady. A young woman from a small town in Pennsylvania, Peggy Sawyer (Mia Kobayashi), arrives late in search of a job in the chorus line. She becomes an instant favourite with the show's leading man, though perhaps not with the leading lady. Later on, when Brock breaks her ankle, Sawyer steps up to take on the role of leading lady.
Directed and choreographed by Lee Proud, this production of 42nd Street is an absolute delight. While the storyline is straightforward to follow, it's the infectious rhythm of tapping feet that truly draws audiences in. Set against a clever fusion of rehearsal room and theatre, Philip Witcomb’s initiative and dynamic design make full use of Kilworth House Theatre’s versatile space, with set pieces gliding seamlessly in and out to inject energy and momentum throughout.
Mia Kobayashi and Brian O’Muiri lead the production with buckets of charm and warmth. O’Muiri’s Billy Lawlor radiates joy from the moment he steps on stage, bringing an infectious energy to every number. Kobayashi is a true standout as Peggy Sawyer. She captures her character’s ambition and underdog determination with an effortless grace that makes her journey through the show so believable. Michelle Bishop strikes the perfect balance as Dorothy Brock, capturing both the character’s diva-like edge and underlying vulnerability.
The dancing in 42nd Street feels like a character in its own right, brought to life by a brilliant and impeccably synchronised ensemble cast. Not a tap is out of place, with crisp, precise rhythms that elevate the entire production. The big musical numbers are delivered with flair, but it’s “We’re in the Money” that truly steals the spotlight, thanks to its dazzling choreography and clever staging. It’s moments like these that make the show such a joyful and memorable experience. The ensemble, which features Katharine Pearson, Cris Penfold, Issie Wilman, Bradley Trevethan, Tia Gyngell, Chris Gray, Esme Kennedy, Benjamin Drew, Imogen Bailey, Joseph Bristow, Danielle Huntley, Theo UK Rose, Dammi Aregbeshola and Mark Austin manage not only to execute every beat of the choreography but transition through a plethora of costume changes with complete ease. Collectively, this is probably one of the most exceptional (and diverse) casts on the Kilworth House Theatre stage that I have seen in the last few years, and I’m absolutely delighted.
This year’s production of 42nd Street is a triumph for the Leicestershire venue. It glitters with charm, oozes of talent, and toe-tapping joy. Come and meet those dancing feet until 13 July, before it’s a summer of love with Grease from 29 July - 7 September.
★ ★ ★ ★
